For indie authors, the journey from initial concept to published book is a deeply personal one.
Each word, each scene, and each character is a reflection of your creative vision.
However, when it comes to assessing the quality of your own work, relying solely on your own judgment can be risky.
The truth is, we are often too close to our writing to see it objectively.
Here’s why external feedback is crucial in the self-publishing process and how it can elevate your book from good to great.
The Subjectivity of Self-Assessment
Writing is an inherently subjective art form.
As an author, you are intimately connected to your story.
This connection can make it difficult to view your work with the critical eye needed for refinement.
When re-reading your own words, your mind often fills in plot gaps or overlooks stylistic inconsistencies because you’re too familiar with the narrative.
What makes sense to you, as the creator, may not be as clear to a reader experiencing your story for the first time.
This subjectivity can lead to blind spots, where crucial elements of storytelling—like pacing, character motivations, or plot coherence—may go unnoticed.
Without external feedback, you risk publishing a book that doesn’t live up to its full potential, simply because you couldn’t see what needed improvement.
The Danger of Echo Chambers
Another common pitfall for indie authors is relying on feedback from friends and family.
While their support is invaluable, their feedback may not always be as critical or honest as you need.
Loved ones are often reluctant to point out flaws in your work, either because they don’t want to hurt your feelings or because they lack the expertise to provide constructive criticism.
This can create an echo chamber, where the true quality of your writing is never fully assessed.
Even if the feedback is positive, it may not address key areas that need development, leaving you with a false sense of confidence in your manuscript.
Breaking out of this echo chamber by seeking diverse, informed perspectives is essential for producing a polished, professional-quality book.
The Role of Professional Feedback
This is where critique partners, writing groups, and professional editors become invaluable.
Critique partners and writing groups can offer fresh eyes and provide feedback from fellow writers who understand the craft.
They can identify weaknesses in plot structure, character development, pacing, and other essential storytelling elements.
These communities can also offer encouragement and motivation, helping you stay committed to improving your work.
Professional editors, on the other hand, bring a level of expertise that can transform your manuscript.
A developmental editor can help you fine-tune your story’s structure, ensuring that each scene advances the plot and deepens character arcs.
A copy editor will focus on language, grammar, and consistency, polishing your manuscript to a professional standard.
By investing in professional feedback, you gain the objectivity and insight necessary to elevate your book to a level that meets readers’ expectations in the competitive self-publishing market.
Learning Through External Inputs
Receiving professional feedback isn’t just about identifying flaws; it’s an invaluable learning opportunity.
Constructive criticism helps you understand the common pitfalls in storytelling, such as inconsistencies in character motivations, sagging middles, or pacing issues.
Through feedback, you can also learn the intricacies of crafting a compelling narrative, from building tension to creating satisfying resolutions.
Over time, this input shapes you into a better writer, honing your ability to self-edit and approach your work with a more critical eye.
The lessons you learn from external feedback on one project can be applied to future projects, continually improving your craft and your chances of success as an indie author.
The Learning Curve
No artist creates a masterpiece on their first attempt, and writing is no different.
It’s a skill that requires practice, patience, and a willingness to learn.
Every draft, every critique, and every revision brings you one step closer to a polished final product.
The willingness to accept and act on feedback is what separates a hobbyist from a professional author.
Valuable resources like Writers Helping Writers, Reedsy, and Scribophile offer tools, advice, and connections to critique partners and editors who can guide you along this learning curve.
Embracing the iterative process of writing, re-writing, critiquing, and polishing is what ultimately leads to the creation of a great book.
In conclusion, while self-assessment is an essential part of the writing process, it should not be the only factor in determining whether your book is ready for publication.
Embracing external feedback—whether from critique partners, writing groups, or professional editors—is crucial for identifying blind spots and ensuring your book meets the high standards of today’s readers.
Writing is not just about putting words on the page; it’s about refining those words through feedback and revision until they shine.
Remember, a great book is not just written; it’s re-written, critiqued, and polished with care.
By valuing external input and viewing writing as a skill to be continually honed, you can create a book that resonates with readers and stands out in the competitive world of indie publishing.
How do you balance self-assessment with external feedback in your writing process? Share your experiences in the comments below!
CherryEdits 